Let me be fair first: as a piece of hardware, this is excellent. 50W wireless charging is genuinely the best in the industry, it’s fast, and it doesn’t cook your phone doing it. On the spec sheet, it’s a win.
The problem is the shape. It’s a stand, so you can’t drop the phone flat onto it the way you would a wireless pad. To charge, you either prop the phone upright in the cradle or clip the coil to the back — and if I’m attaching a thing to the back of my phone to charge it, I’ve reinvented the wired charger, just slower and more awkward.
Which is the whole tension. If I’m going to physically connect something anyway, I’ll grab the 120W cable that charges faster and costs a fraction as much. The wireless magic is supposed to be “set it down and walk away,” and this design quietly takes that away. Brilliant charging, wrapped around a use case it undermines. Hence: mixed, not bad — but I don’t reach for it.